| 04/06/1945 | Father F. Joseph Bilstein |
| 07/02/1945 | Father Leo J. Dufrane |
| 02/18/1946 | Father Florian DelFosse |
| 07/18/1946 | Father Francis J. McAuliffe |
| 03/10/1948 | Father Nicholas Keller |
| 11/04/1948 | Father William B. Hordeman |
| 11/18/1948 | Father Joseph C. Adler |
| 10/23/1949 | Father Gustave Hottenroth |
| 07/09/1951 | Father Aquinas Knoff |
| 02/10/1952 | Father John Hosinski |
| 08/21/1952 | Father Paul A. Anderson |
| 10/21/1952 | Father F. Joseph Mutch |
| 12/31/1952 | Father Edward J. Freiburger |
| 11/26/1954 | Father D. Leo Faurote |
| 11/06/1955 | Father Joseph A. Suelzer |
| 05/14/1956 | Father John A. McCarthy |
| 12/16/1956 | Father Hubert H. Kueches |
| 11/20/1957 | Bishop John G. Bennett |
| 04/30/1957 | Msgr. Michael Aichinger |
| 01/27/1959 | Father Edward Dempsey |
| 04/04/1960 | Msgr. Michael Chapman |
| 08/09/1960 | Father John J. Harbrecht |
| 03/02/1961 | Father James E. Quinn |
| 07/22/1961 | Father John E. Dillon |
| 08/22/1962 | Msgr. Thomas Travers |
| 10/13/1962 | Father Francis H. Liebert |
| 12/10/1963 | Msgr. Robert J. Halpin |
| 04/04/1964 | Father Ambrose A. Kohne |
| 06/07/1964 | Msgr. Felix T. Seroczynski |
| 06/24/1964 | Father Edward T. Fallon |
| 06/30/1964 | Father Joseph A. Lynn |
| 07/27/1964 | Father Matthew N. Drennan |
| 05/19/1965 | Msgr. Leo A. Breitenbach |
| 11/29/1965 | Father James M. Fitzgerald |
| 12/12/1966 | Father James B. Thornton |
| 03/30/1968 | Father Joseph C. Keating |
| 06/21/1968 | Father J. Edward Holland |
| 09/05/1968 | Msgr. Aloysius Copenolle |
| 09/21/1968 | Father Jerome C. Walski |
| 11/19/1970 | Father James H. Moran |
| 01/22/1971 | Father Robert L. Gerth |
| 04/09/1972 | Msgr. Paul A. Welsh |
| 08/05/1972 | Father Otto A. Peters |
| 03/15/1973 | Father James H. Leah |
| 07/30/1973 | Father Robert W. Sorg |
| 03/14/1974 | Father Charles W. Muller |
| 05/29/1974 | Father M. Joseph McDonnell |
| 05/08/1976 | Father Leo A. Scheetz |
| 04/10/1977 | Msgr. John P. Schall |
| 05/23/1977 | Msgr. Francis G. Kienly |
| 03/13/1978 | Father Francis J. Meehan |
| 10/23/1978 | Father Leo P. McHale |
| 11/12/1978 | Father Peter VanTiel |
| 03/24/1979 | Father Charles J. A. Scholl |
| 05/09/1979 | Father Michael A. Reineck |
| 05/12/1980 | Father George T. Loner |
| 06/13/1980 | Father James B. McKeown |
| 09/09/1981 | Father John P. Cunningham |
| 01/25/1984 | Bishop George A. Fulcher |
| 01/24/1985 | Msgr. Edgar J. Cyr |
| 09/05/1985 | Msgr. Theodore J. Hammes |
| 11/10/1986 | Father Joseph R. Ackerman |
| 07/04/1988 | Father Richard A. Smith |
| 12/26/1988 | Father Costabile R. Guariglia |
| 05/17/1989 | Father Francis J. Niesen |
| 06/04/1989 | Father Donald J. Tracey |
| 01/05/1991 | Father Cornelius J. Kelly |
| 03/07/1991 | Bishop Raymond J. Gallagher |
| 03/28/1991 | Msgr. Henry F. Ward |
| 10/18/1991 | Father Thomas F. Timmerman |
| 09/18/1992 | Msgr. Emil A. Schweier |
| 10/23/1992 | Father David D. Clifford |
| 05/08/1993 | Father Roy T. Fennessy |
| 07/31/1993 | Father Roderick H. Berns |
| 08/05/1993 | Father Ronald O. Maupin |
| 08/17/1993 | Father Raymond H. Wieber |
| 03/21/1994 | Father John W. Bouvier |
| 06/21/1995 | Father Edward J. Stone |
| 06/06/1996 | Father Richard A. Cooley |
| 10/01/1996 | Father George B. Lanning |
| 09/29/1997 | Father Duane M. Craycraft |
| 12/04/1997 | Father Frederick J. Perry |
| 12/10/1997 | Rev. Mr. Bruce Koenig |
| 01/16/1998 | Father Thomas O. Heilman |
| 06/17/1998 | John Joseph Cardinal Carberry |
| 09/07/1998 | Msgr. Arthur A. Sego |
| 03/08/1999 | Father Francis M. Scheck |
| 09/06/2000 | Msgr. Sylvester P. Klein |
| 12/01/2000 | Father Bernard J. Carr |
| 04/30/2001 | Father Leo J. Haigerty |
| 06/09/2001 | Father Leo A. Piguet |
| 10/16/2001 | Msgr. Maurice D. Foley |
| 07/24/2002 | Father A. Leonard Reemmer |
| 09/18/2002 | Father Rick G. Tucker |
| 05/27/2003 | Father Robert J. Fosselman |
| 10/06/2003 | Father William R. Grady |
| 03/01/2004 | Father Fred A. Schroeder |
| 03/10/2004 | Father Fred H. Gschwind |
| 04/22/2004 | Father Jack F. Trippel |
| 12/05/2004 | Father Kenneth T. Raczek |
| 08/04/2005 | Father Harold E. Weller |
| 12/21/2005 | Father Charles L Kline |
| 05/22/2006 | Deacon Albert McConahay |
| 08/28/2006 | Father Carl E. Eckert |
| 12/15/2006 | Father Bernard Lutkenhoff |
| 03/11/2007 | Father Donald E. Hardebeck |
| 04/14/2007 | Father Anthony J. Prosen |
| 09/02/2008 | Father Gordon P. Wagoner |
| 10/13/2008 | Father Richard E. Miller |
| 12/15/2008 | Father Victor P. Schott |
| 08/23/2009 | Father Charles W. Remaklus |
| 02/13/2010 | Father Thomas J. Zimmer |
| 02/15/2010 | Father Douglas M. McCormack |
| 03/06/2010 | Father John A. Bach |
| 09/16/2010 | Father Joseph E. Jacob |
| 11/23/2010 | Father John C. Schultz |
| 12/06/2010 | Father Donald B. Vernon |
| 04/19/2011 | Father Melvin J. Bennett |
| 06/01/2011 | Father Maurice R. Miller |
| 11/20/2012 | Father Jeldo J. Schiavone |
| 02/15/2013 | Father Louis S. Heitz |
| 02/28/2013 | Deacon James MacDougall |
| 10/28/2013 | Father James T. Keane |
| 11/15/2013 | Msgr. Fred E. Potthoff |
| 11/24/2013 | Father David M. Douglas |
| 06/06/2014 | Father Barry R. Gross |
| 07/03/2014 | Father Joseph J. Bruetsch |
| 05/07/2015 | Father Joseph R. Ruffing |
| 05/24/2015 | Father Edward S. Matuszak |
| 07/19/2015 | Father Donald J. Eder |
| 03/14/2017 | Father Edward F. Dhondt |
| 04/06/2017 | Father William R. Vath |
| 08/27/2017 | Father John Zahn |
| 09/29/2017 | Father Herbert R. Woolson |
| 02/27/2018 | Father George Askar |
| 06/27/2018 | Father Michael A. Ondo |
| 07/02/2018 | Father Joseph W. Grace |
| 10/22/2018 | Father Ambrose M. Ziegler |
| 12/03/2018 | Father Philip Haslinger |
| 12/09/2018 | Father Timothy Kroeger |
| 06/10/2019 | Father James Goodrum |
| 8/18/2019 | Deacon Domingo Castillo |
| 09/27/2019 | Father Thomas Fox |
| 10/11/2020 | Father Christopher Roberts |
| 03/03/2021 | Father James R. Bates |
| 07/10/2021 | Father Gerald J. Borawski |
| 11/10/2021 | Father Alejandro M. Paternoster |
| 12/17/2021 | Father Philip T. Bowers |
| 6/14/2022 | Father W. Michael Kettron, J.C.D. |
| 8/21/2023 | Father Robert J. Bernotas |
| 11/18/2024 | Father Richard Puetz |
| 1/6/2025 | Bishop William L. Higi |
| 2/8/2025 | Deacon John R. Jezierski |
| 6/2/2025 | Deacon Ronald Morrow |